Everybody has dating tales of woe. I knew this when I was a youngster living in Arizona, but I also knew that the odds were even more against me. I was a fish out of water there, and the men I managed to dig up were few and far between. I had only one long-term relationship before I moved to New York City, and that was during college, and it was a complete disaster. He was a great guy, but our overwhelming personal issues were constantly battling for attention in what my mom termed "a buffet of neurosis." After a few more years of hunting and pecking, I finally came to terms with the fact that, regardless of the dating scene, Arizona in general just wasn't for me. So I took off for the great beyond to seek my destiny.
My very first date in New York City was with a Jewish lawyer. You can imagine my grandmother's delight. Fresh off the boat, and here I was already fishing from the most coveted pool. My uncle who, not coincidentally, is also a Jewish lawyer, set me up with with him, earning him major brownie points with the family.
Since I was still learning my way around the city, the Jewish Lawyer kindly met me near my office and took the reigns of our date. After a brief stop at the ATM I found myself staring up at the intimidating entrance to The Four Seasons.
The scenario: I am 24. I am wearing a suit that is, literally, held together with safety pins and purchased at the JC Penney outlet. I am new to New York City. I am on a blind date, which is enormously stressful in any situation, and I am sitting in the lounge area, in a big overstuffed armchair, of the Four Seasons. I am too nervous to order anything but a Diet Coke, and am confused when I am unable to sip through what appears to be a glass straw. Hey, I'm thinking to myself, A glass straw! Must be a classy-New-York kind of thing.
But after my face nearly caved in trying to slurp through the fancy glass straw, I drew back and realized it was actually a stirrer. Meant to stir the lemon wedge that still lay untouched and unnoticed on a dainty little plate to one side of the table. Apparently when you spend $6 on a Diet Coke, the lemon comes with.
Heh heh. Oops.
Luckily my date did not notice my faux-paus, as he was busy detailing the entire script, almost verbatim, of the most recent Seinfeld episode. He went on to regale me with further tales of Seinfeld which, while making for extraordinarily dull conversation, proved to be less dull than when he actually talked about himself.
That first date was also the last.
Over the years I went on many, many, many dates. I tried all sorts of dating techniques. Don't get me wrong. I did have a few long-term relationships in there. I dated one guy for a year and half, and another for almost two. I was in New York a total of six years, which means I spent less than half of them single. As I write that, it doesn't seem so bad. But that's a lot of Saturday nights spent alone in my apartment listening to drunk couples on the street having a raucously good time while I channel-surfed and ate Chinese take-out straight from the carton. On the bright side, I learned how to use chopsticks like a native.
The search for the decent single man in New York was, in my opinion, fairly accurately documented in the Sex and the City series. What wasn't so accurate, at least in my particular case, was the amount of sex the ladies managed to have despite all the weirdos they dated. Perhaps I was just a little more picky about who I went to bed with. Yes, I am pretty sure that's it.
I heard about a Temple on the Upper East Side that was sort of known for being a singles hot-spot. Rumor had it you could appeal directly to the Rabbi and she would personally set you up with someone. De-singling Jews is practically part of the religion. So I attended a service but all that talk about God made my skin crawl and I felt horribly out of place. There were hundreds of young people in attendance, all of them, I was certain, far more knowledgeable than me about this religion I was born into but never practiced. If I did manage to meet anybody this way I would be immediately denounced as a fraud. Faking religion to get a date is worse than stuffing your bra with Kleenex. I ducked out early and never said a word to anyone.
I went to a dating seminar, where you are given a number, and then they go around the room and allow each person to sell themselves for about five minutes. After that traumatic experience you're allowed out of your chair to mingle while drinking watery punch and eating cookies that taste like cardboard. Then you filled in the numbers of the people you would go out with on a bubble sheet reminiscent of the SAT. If your number was also selected by the ones you selected then you exchanged phone numbers and went on a date. I have to say, that experience was quite an ego boost. There were hardly any attractive people in attendance so I was, by default, pretty popular. The odds were in my favor. I felt for a brief moment like the belle of the ball, surrounded by horrifically shy, balding, short men who surreptitiously snuck up and thrust a business card in my hand before skulking off again. I got a couple dates out of that, but nothing earth-shattering.
In between relationships I tried online dating. There was a site all the girls in the office were talking about that was specifically for Jewish singles. I was still convinced that, although I was not a religious person, the cultural aspects of being Jewish provided enough common ground that it made sense to pursue the yarmulke-set. So I signed up and went on a series of the worst dates in history. The first guy never took his eyes off the Simpsons, which was playing on the TV above the bar where we met. I mean, he was like emotionally ill-prepared to do anything but watch television. When I tried to interact with him he appeared so irritated by the interruption that I felt like I'd plopped down uninvited in his living room.
The next date called me at 8:30pm one weekday night and asked me if I wanted to meet him in a few minutes at a coffee shop around the corner. What the hell? I thought. Why not? So I gussied up a bit and headed over. "You're spontaneous!" he said after we'd introduced ourselves and pulled chairs up to a table. "I love that!" He then proceeded to agitatedly beat out a rhythm on the table that made sense only to him while bobbing his head back and forth and darting his eyes around the room like he expected the police to burst in at any minute and drag him off. It was probably a pretty realistic fear since he was clearly sky-high on something. Later he confirmed this by leaning over to me and confessing in a whisper, "Before I came to meet you, I did a LOT of drugs." This was after I'd learned he was a doctor. A podiatrist, but still. I wouldn't want that guy touching any part of me, not even my feet.
The third guy I met from the site seemed really great on paper. He worked as a writer for Comedy Central and his emails were hilarious. I agreed to meet him for drinks after work one evening and I was really hopeful about this one. But as soon as I saw him my stomach dropped. I hate to be the type of person who makes snap judgements based solely on appearance, particularly when up until I saw the guy I had nothing but positive vibes. But really, you can't help who you are attracted to, right? That's an old excuse for bad behavior but it also happens to be true.
The guy was very tall and very thin. I think he must have been self-conscious about his height because he sat hunched over to the point that his back actually bowed behind his head. Despite being in his mid-twenties he had the complexion of a boy tortured by acne. He was so sweet. He brought along a Cosmo quiz to break the ice, and he was very funny in a self-deprecating kind of way. Unfortunately most of what he said was accompanied with spittle, so that as the evening progressed I first leaned back in my chair and then started to ever so casually scoot further and further back from the table.
At the end of the date he handed me a piece of paper with several phone numbers on it. "I would really like it if you called me," he said hopelessly. "But I rarely get second dates."
I felt terrible about it, but he wasn't going to get a second date this time, either. When I told my mom about the evening she said, "What's the matter? You have something against spitting hunchbacks? This is how I raised you?"
She was kidding. I think.
After that I gave up on J-Date. I had met nothing but crazy people on that site which led me to wonder if perhaps that was a common trait among Jewish people, among men, among people who looked for dates online, or all of the above. In any case, that's when I met someone with whom I had a serious relationship for the next two years. Unfortunately, as much as I liked him, it wasn't meant to be and eventually we split up.
Shortly after that I heard from a friend of mine that my long-ago college boyfriend, the one with whom I grazed at the buffet of neurosis, was back in Arizona. So when I headed home for the holidays that year I got in touch with him and we agreed to meet for dinner. When we saw each other again after nearly seven years, the electricity was immediate and obvious.
In spite of that, this wasn't something I intended to pursue. First of all, been there, done that. Second, he lived across the country from me and I wasn't about to give up New York. Third, he was recently divorced and struggling through the inescapable emotional and financial residue that goes along with any marital break-up, no matter how amicable. Not someone any single woman should touch with a ten-foot pole. But compared with my dating history in New York City, he was Prince-fucking-Charming.
We continued to talk long-distance and before I knew it, I was hooked. He wasn't Prince Charming - I'd long ago given up the notion that any man was or should be - but he was my best friend and closest confidant and I was madly in love. Eventually it came down to either solving the long-distance problem or discontinuing the relationship. I spent many hours over drinks at various New York bars lamenting this decision. Despite how much I loved him, there was the fact that, well, I had a rent-controlled apartment in New York City. Plus he had been married before and had some baggage from his past that didn't sit well with me. His first wife was a tall, thin, very attractive woman with whom I had nothing in common which led me to believe he was either crazy for being with her, or crazy for wanting to be with me. But either way, he came out crazy.
While I debated what to do I started dating the Matt Damon Lawyer. I call him this because a) he looked exactly like a shorter version of Matt Damon and b) he was a lawyer. The Matt Damon Lawyer and I went on six first dates. What I mean by that is every date we went on never got past that awkward small-talk stage. We never grew more comfortable with each other or progressed to a kiss good night. There was clearly nothing inspirational to tap there, but he kept asking me out and I kept saying yes and I have a feeling we were both doing so for the same reason - we were both hung up on other people we thought less appropriate. Eventually I just gave up. Obviously I was in love with someone else if a lawyer who looked like Matt Damon couldn't do it for me.
But I wasn't ready to give up New York, Tom still hadn't finalized his divorce, and he was, at that time, fairly directionless in general. And yet the time apart was growing more and more intolerable. Over margaritas I detailed this to my friend Mark who was able, in his very Mark-like way, to boil it down to a sentence: "Listen, if you can talk and you can fuck, the rest are just details."
So I did it. I left New York for the boy, despite every feminist instinct screaming at my foolishness. I had to know. And New York would always be there, with all its crazies looking for dates.
As it turns out, I ended up marrying the guy.
The moral of the story? This is great...
Like Dorothy, I had to go to Oz to discover that what I wanted had been in my own back yard all along. I just hadn't been ready to recognize it till I'd journeyed through a land filled with drug addicts, emotional midgets and spitting hunchbacks (oh my) through whom I eventually discovered the ways of my heart.